Daughter Who Threatened Mother With Weapon During Probation Gets Prison Term
A daughter who was given a chance to live without standing trial again (a suspended sentence) ended up behind bars after threatening and assaulting her mother with a weapon during that period. The Chuncheon District Court, in an appellate trial, sentenced 25-year-old Mr. A, who had been indicted and detained on charges including special intimidation of an ascendant, to one year in prison, the same as in the original ruling.
Mr. A had previously wielded a weapon against his biological father and received a suspended sentence. He was brought to trial on charges of threatening and assaulting his mother, a woman in her 40s, with a weapon while drinking with her at an apartment in Wonju, Gangwon Province, in March. Mr. A denied the charges to the end, claiming he never threatened or assaulted his mother while holding a weapon.
The first-instance court, however, ruled that even if he did not grip the weapon, keeping it in a state where it could immediately be used in a crime could be considered carrying a dangerous object. The court also cited his prior record of threatening his father with a weapon and the urgency of the situation, which drove the mother to ask an acquaintance to call the police, as grounds for rejecting his claims.
While taking into account that the victim did not wish to see her daughter punished, the first-instance court chose a prison sentence. The court pointed out: "The defendant committed a crime against his own mother while serving a probation period for attempted murder of his biological father; the nature of the offense is poor, and the degree of social condemnation is not insignificant."
On appeal, Mr. A's side changed its logic and challenged the indictment itself. It argued that since intimidation and assault of an ascendant are offenses subject to a complaint requirement—meaning prosecution is not possible if the victim does not wish for punishment—the indictment should be dismissed, given that the mother had stated she did not wish for her daughter's punishment.
In response, the appellate court found the mother's initial statements credible. Immediately after the incident, she specifically told police that her daughter had held a weapon and threatened her companion dog. She later changed her statement during the prosecutor's investigation and in the first-instance trial, saying in essence that she had not directly seen him holding the weapon, but she only explained during the police investigation that she had "given false testimony out of anger." Regarding the circumstances of the mother's change in testimony, the court also concluded, based on jail and prison visitation recordings, that Mr. A had demanded that she change her statement.
