Kim Min-jeon: "How Could the December 3 Martial Law Be an Insurrection?"
"How could the December 3 emergency martial law be an insurrection?" Rep. Kim Min-jeon of the People Power Party pushed back against the Supreme Court's ruling in a Facebook post on the 19th, arguing that an insurrection could not have taken place because former President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law under the Constitution and lifted it when the National Assembly demanded its rescission. Why, then, did the Supreme Court deem the December 3 martial law an act of insurrection?
The People Power Party's objections run directly counter to the Supreme Court's full-bench judgment. In the appellate ruling delivered that day under Chief Justice Cho Hee-de as presiding justice and Justice Oh Kyung-mi as the reporting justice, the Court, while overturning and remanding some charges in the insurrection case involving former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo's alleged involvement in key insurrection-related duties, defined the December 3 martial law as an unconstitutional, unlawful act of insurrection that violated the constitutional order and infringed on citizens' fundamental rights. The Court found that former President Yoon effectively bypassed deliberation by the State Council when he declared martial law, with the intent of seizing control of the National Assembly and media outlets by deploying troops and police. Justices Oh Kyung-mi, Shin Sook-hee, and Kim Sung-soo, diverging from the majority opinion, found that former Prime Minister Han had harbored the purpose of disrupting constitutional order in his involvement in convening the State Council ahead of the martial law declaration.
The People Power Party also took aim at Justice Oh, who authored a minority opinion. In a statement on November 19, party spokesperson Cho Yong-sul said that Justice Oh showed an emotional attitude, making faces as she read her dissenting opinion, and repeatedly referred to the former president as "Yoon Suk Yeol" rather than by his official title or as the defendant. "We express deep regret over Justice Oh Kyung-mi's demeanor and mindset, which resembled those of a Democratic Party spokesperson, in the Supreme Court, which must above all be impartial," he said.
There was also pushback against the Democratic Party's move to pursue the impeachment of Chief Justice Cho Hee-de even though the Supreme Court confirmed the martial law's unconstitutionality. After the ruling on the 19th, the Democratic Party announced at an evening emergency caucus meeting that it would pursue Chief Justice Cho's impeachment, with plans to formally adopt it as a party position at a caucus meeting on the 20th. On the 20th, People Power Party Rep. Yoon Sang-hyun wrote on Facebook: "The Supreme Court made clear that the martial law was unconstitutional and unlawful and that there was nothing wrong with the guilty verdicts on insurrection charges, so what part of the ruling, exactly, amounts to echoing an insurrection?" He added that the party should stop its impeachment drive against Chief Justice Cho. At a field policy coordination meeting held on Hongdae street in Mapo-gu, Seoul, on the 20th, People Power Party floor leader Jeong Jeom-sik urged an end to pressure on the judiciary, saying, "Pursuing the impeachment of the chief justice because one dislikes the verdict is madness."
