Reconstruction Levy Now Exceeds 100 Million Won Per Union Member
As reconstruction levies are imposed in earnest, the average amount owed by each union member has surpassed 100 million won. The larger the levy, the smaller the profits union members who took part in reconstruction projects actually take home. Narrowing the scope to reconstruction complexes in Seoul, the average levy reaches 160 million won, according to tallies.
The reconstruction levy is a payment owed to the government when profits from reconstruction — specifically, the portion remaining after deductions (excess profit) — exceed 80 million won. The larger the profit, the higher the payment. Excess profit is calculated by converting, per union member, the amount remaining after deducting the housing price at the time of union establishment approval, normal housing price appreciation, and development costs from the housing price on the completion date. If a project is delayed and more than 10 years elapse between union establishment approval and completion, the housing price 10 years before the completion date is used as the baseline.
The excess profit calculation method itself is a subject of legal dispute. Kim Ye-rim, managing partner at Simmok Law Firm, pointed to the housing price valuation method and the scope of deductible costs as points of contention.
While unions must collect the reconstruction levy from members and pay it to administrative authorities, they are granted considerable discretion in how they collect it. Unlike the law, which explicitly designates who is obligated to pay the levy to the state, the collection procedure from union members is merely left to unions to set out in their management and disposition plans. Collection standards may therefore vary from complex to complex, and the criteria for handling members eligible for exemptions or payment deferrals remain unclear. Observers note that who ultimately bears the levy can shift depending on how a union determines which members are subject to it.
Kim Ye-rim of Simmok Law Firm stressed that statutes must be overhauled in a detailed and consistent manner to reduce disputes. Because the levy is an unfavorable disposition, she said, clear legal grounds are essential to minimize infringement on citizens' property rights.
