Kim Keon-hee's 4-Year Prison Term Finalized at Supreme Court
The Supreme Court's en banc bench (a panel in which all 12 justices participate) on the 19th finalized a four-year prison sentence for Kim Keon-hee in the 'three scandals' case, and issued a remand (sending the case back to a lower court for retrial) in the case of former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo. The fact that this ruling was made by the full en banc bench rather than a smaller division of four justices underscores the gravity of the two cases.
Kim was indicted over what are known as the three scandals: the Deutsche Motors stock manipulation scheme, her acceptance of a Chanel handbag from the Unification Church under the guise of a requested favor, and her receipt of free opinion polls from Myeong Tae-gyun. She was sentenced to one year and eight months in prison in the first trial and four years in the second, and the Supreme Court upheld the second-trial sentence as is.
Regarding the allegation of free opinion polls from Myeong Tae-gyun, the Supreme Court found the lower court's reasoning justified—that the polls provided free of charge do not constitute a property benefit under the Political Funds Act. Both the first and second trials had acquitted her on this charge.
Former Prime Minister Han was sentenced to 23 years in prison in the first trial and 15 years in the second. The Supreme Court overturned the ruling, citing misinterpretations of legal principles on some issues and an incomplete review of necessary matters, and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court. The court found that the purpose of undermining constitutional order was not proven with respect to his act of recommending that the State Council meeting be held before the declaration of martial law. Some justices, including Justice Oh Kyung-mi, issued dissenting opinions against this majority view.
The Supreme Court extended former Prime Minister Han's detention period by two months. He will receive a renewed appellate ruling from the Seoul High Court while remaining in custody.
