Democrats to File Impeachment Motion Against Chief Justice Cho on December 3
The Democratic Party has effectively settled on December 3 as the date to file an impeachment motion against Chief Justice of the Supreme Court Cho Hee-de.
Cho Kye-won, spokesperson for the Democratic Party of Korea, said at a briefing on the 21st regarding the timing of the impeachment motion that "there is a consensus on filing it on the December 3 milestone." December 3 marks the day former President Yoon Suk-yeol declared martial law, and the ruling party refers to it as the "second anniversary of the insurrection," treating it as a symbolic date for holding the judiciary accountable. The Democratic Party has already adopted the impeachment as an official party position and has begun formal procedures.
Why Impeach the Chief Justice?
The impeachment drive stems from the ruling party's judgment on the judiciary's role and responsibility following the martial law crisis. The Democratic Party has raised issues including the fact that Chief Justice Cho joined a conservative group while serving as Chief Justice, arguing that such conduct violates the political neutrality of the judiciary. The ruling party is also seen as seeking symbolic weight in the timing of the motion to match the gravity of the impeachment grounds. Choosing the "second anniversary of the insurrection" as the milestone is a strategy to directly tie the justification for impeachment to the judiciary's responsibility for the martial law crisis.
Impeachment Procedure and Immediate Effects
Procedurally, an impeachment motion against the Chief Justice can be filed by one-third or more of the National Assembly's sitting members, and passage in a plenary vote requires majority approval plus a two-thirds supermajority. With the Democratic Party and other opposition seats, the party can meet both the filing and passage requirements. If the motion passes the National Assembly, Chief Justice Cho will be immediately suspended from duty pending a final ruling by the Constitutional Court. However, if the court dismisses the case, the impeachment fails and the Chief Justice returns to his duties.
Notably, from the moment proceedings begin, the most senior justice will assume the Chief Justice's duties in an acting capacity. This means a months-long leadership vacuum at the top of the judiciary, which could have real consequences for Supreme Court operations and the scheduling of major cases.
Ruling and Opposition Clash Reaches Breaking Point
The People Power Party's backlash is fierce. At a large-scale protest rally in Daegu on the 21st, the party condemned the ruling party's ramming through of the "fabricated indictment special counsel act" and Chief Justice Cho's impeachment, labeling both "treason." The People Power Party maintains that the impeachment drive destroys constitutional order, pressing that "each and every Democratic lawmaker who joins the impeachment must bear political responsibility if the Constitutional Court dismisses the motion." With both sides branding each other as forces of constitutional destruction, the National Assembly faces a climactic December showdown as the special counsel act revote and the impeachment filing converge.
Timeline and Implications
If the Democratic Party files the impeachment motion around December 3, it is likely to be put to a plenary vote soon after. If the ruling party sets the agenda, it can choose the timing of the vote. Given that the Constitutional Court's final ruling could take considerable time, a scenario in which the Chief Justice remains suspended into the first half of next year cannot be ruled out. As the impeachment of a head of the judiciary is unprecedented in the nation's constitutional history, legal disputes over the legitimacy of the process and political infighting are expected to far outlast the legislative calendar.
